BurtonReviews Split: Are You Talking to Me?..Or Him?..Or Her?..Etcetera
(Image sourced from http://www.hercampus.com/school/ucf/split-and-stigma-shyamalans-new-controversial-movie-advocates-mental-health)
After just over a decade of awful box office and critical
bombs such as the painful The Last Airbender in 2010 and the mind numbingly
boring After Earth in 2013, the release of The Visit in 2015 seemed to declare
M. Night Shyamalan’s return to actually well-crafted and enjoyable film making
as he scaled back the scope of his films to bring a more relatable and
engrossing edge to his films that seemed lacking in the past decade of his
filmography. Now, with the release of Split, will M. Night be able to remain on
this re-ascension to greatness, or falter once again?
The story of Split sees three teenage girls: the outcast with
obvious deep emotional issues, Anya Taylor-Joy as Cass Cooke, the popular girl
who has never had to worry about anything in her life before, Haley Lu
Richardson Claire Benoit, and her best friend, Jessica Sula as Marcia, are
kidnapped by a sinister glasses wearing James McAvoy and taken to vague and
eerily basic locked bedroom, with adjoining bathroom of course. When McAvoy re-enters, this time wearing a
dress and a whole new set of mannerisms and speech pattern, it is clear there
is more to this hostage situation than it seems. And so the horror with a twist
begins as the girls must escape from a man with 23 personalities all stuck in
his head and fighting for dominance.
If there is anything that Split proves, it is that M. Night
is back. With his hands all over both the directing and script writing for this
movie, M. Night has crafted a truly fascinating and enthralling plot that had
me constantly trying to figure out just how McAvoy’s character, or characters,
worked as he skilfully unpeeled just enough of the mystery to have me
biting-at-the-bit for more.
(Image sourced from https://mic.com/articles/149959/m-night-shyamalan-s-split-trailer-suggests-a-movie-rife-with-mental-illness-stigma)
The way the script effortlessly, and subtly, seeds in ideas and a whole new set of terms for his set of extremely intense circumstances is something surely to be commended.
But the excellent scripting would have been for naught if
there wasn’t an incredibly talented actor to bring to life a vast majority of
these 23 unique personalities in a believable and distinguishable enough way.
Thankfully with James McAvoy at the helm of this movie, this daunting task was
in probably the best hands. While McAvoy has starred in a myriad of other films
at this point, his stint as the young Professor X in the X Men franchise being
one of many highlights, it is in Split that he really gets to tense his
muscles, both figuratively and literally, as his range in performance,
effortlessly switching from a disillusioned nine year old, to a sassy but firm
middle-aged woman, then sliding perfectly into a man obsessed with the
intricacies of history, was nothing less than astounding. McAvoy completely
disappeared into his roles, at the attention to detail he put in to create such
fleshed out, living, breathing facets of this man’s fractured psyche is not
only commendable, but inspiring and has changed how I look at the actor from
this point on.
(Image sourced from http://bloody-disgusting.com/reviews/3408190/fantastic-fest-review-split-shyamalan/)
Another thing that has made me change how I look at the actor
was just how damn unsettling he was in every single scene of this film. The
unpredictability of who the three teenage girls were going to have to encounter
next added to just how powerful McAvoy’s screen presence was each and every
time he stepped on screen, instantly created this inescapable atmosphere of
tension and as McAvoy commanded the room to his unnerving whim.
And it is this effect that McAvoy brings that makes it so
when the events of the film really hit the fan, it is intense as all hell. In
the brutal game of cat and mouse that the finale of this movie becomes, my
heart was pounding out of my chest as the girls desperately tried to escape the
many clutches of this unstoppable man, and even before all that, it feels as if
the girls’ lives are always hanging on a thread and any influx in McAvoy’s current
persona’s mood, or outburst of emotion could sound the end of one hostage’s
life.
Overall M. Night is definitely back, and if this fascinating
story that never allows you to settle into peace or quiet as the characters are
always dangled on a knifes edge, coupled with McAvoy’s awe inspiring range of
characters and acting chops, doesn’t prove that to you, I don’t know what will.
Split = 8.5/10
Why not check out my YouTube channel, BurtonReviews, where I upload awesome gaming montages put to badass songs or scores every Sunday. Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCbUfnyezvQsVsDgN3TGRh1Q
Thanks for reading and I hope you enjoyed!
Hi Sam,
ReplyDeleteI couldn't agree more that M. Night has certainly come a long way back towards good things in the past few years, however I believe he's not quite there yet.
Personally I felt slightly lost watching Split, as I just couldn't quite find an emotional tether from either of the main characters. I'll admit there was an attempt to create empathy for the girl with the flashbacks, but they did more to confuse me than to make me feel sorry for her. Right at the end when it turned out she was "impure", as she had been abused, then it created the empathy for her, but by that point it was too late and there was no real need to feel scared for her as she was safe and the film was at an end.
So then we come to the many characters embodied by Keith. I feel like this character is genius and completely agree about James McAvoy's portrayal being incredible! However I feel like this is where the emotional tether should have been. Keith, more than anything, was misunderstood and he was just trying to protect himself. (In fact they kept on mentioning that general public were afraid of people like Keith, but this was never actually shown, just spoken of - if we were shown him being abused because he was different, then that would have created the empathy it was lacking.) Additionally what was missing from this character was a redeeming moment, that showed he wasn't just a monster solely for the purpose of being used in a horror film, but instead a scared human being that was trying to protect himself from a world trying to harm him. Unfortunately he and "the beast" were used as a cheap horror trick that left no lasting impression. (I personally feel the end of the film could have been like the scene on the roof at the end of Blade Runner, if you've seen that. {If you haven't, I highly recommend it}).
So basically what I'm trying to say is I feel that this film was a horror film trying to be something more. It was so close to being something great, but instead fell into the hole that so many other horror films do. It failed to create true empathy for the characters and so the tension built up (whilst still felt in the moment) is quickly lost and when I left the cinema, it no real lasting affect on me.
However from what rumours I have heard, a sequel to Split is in development and so there may be something truly great to come of Keith yet!
Hi Joe, sorry to say but I disagree about the emotional connection, while finding out more about Keith was the main hook of the film, I really felt for the main hostage, and her flashbacks from the 2nd one on just made me empathise with her even more and hope for her survival because of after everything she's been through, she bloody deserves it.
DeleteWith Keith, o thought when the real him came back it was subtly impactful, seeing just how normal and down trodden this guy was brought home how unfair his life had been because he was just a normal guy who's had his life pretty much taken from him for his own protection by his guardians who also happen to inhabit the same body.
I get all of your well written point (extra points for that btw) and can see how the film can feel like a above average, just another horror film, but for me there was a lasting impression, and I can't wait to see where McAvoy is taken next.